Xbox Elite Controller Series 2 review: "Makes the best controller even better"

Xbox Elite wireless controller Series 2 review
(Image: © Microsoft)

GamesRadar+ Verdict

The Xbox Elite Controller Series 2 makes loads of smart changes that correct, improve, and upgrade the best controller on the market.


  • +

    Wireless charging

  • +

    New system-level customization options

  • +

    Adjustable analog stick tension and trigger travel

  • +

    Better balanced


  • -

    Very expensive

  • -

    Onboard memory only stores one profile

Why you can trust GamesRadar+ Our experts review games, movies and tech over countless hours, so you can choose the best for you. Find out more about our reviews policy.

When looking at the prospect of the new Xbox Elite Controller Series 2 you're probably thinking, 'How do you make the best controller even better?' Microsoft’s original Xbox Elite controller changed the way we think about gamepads when it launched in 2015. Until that point, the default controller for each platform was the gold standard, and everything else was either a niche tool for a specific type of game, like a fight stick, or an inferior imitation. 

With the Elite, Microsoft opened the door to the idea that there’s room for growth with its extra customization options and ergonomic rear paddle inputs. 

The Xbox Elite Series 2 improves the expanded feature-set of the first Elite in many ways, giving you more ways to remake your controller to run in a way that feels natural to you and you alone. Some of those features are common-sense updates, but you may be surprised by their impact. Truly, whether you are a power user looking to bend every game experience to your will, the way PC players tend to on a mouse and keyboard, or you simply want the most comfortable controller available, the Xbox Elite Controller Series 2 will give you what you need, unless you're looking for a cheap Xbox One controller price that is.

What feels like a single monumental upgrade is actually the sum of many, many improvements, big and small. The major improvements, compared to the standard Xbox One controller, are very similar. It offers the ability to remap controls, customize your how the controller feels and, of course, gives you four horizontally mounted paddle inputs that can be used to replace or augment the face buttons. Each of these broad upgrades, however, has more to offer in the Series 2.

What's new with the Xbox Elite Controller Series 2?

The Xbox One Elite Series 2 features new textured grips, which now completely cover the legs of the controller, and reach up the sides all the way to the triggers. Other than when pressing a button or paddle, you won’t naturally rest your finger on an untextured face. The grip pattern itself is low-profile, and does not seem prone to scratching or wearing down.

The replaceable parts - the paddles; textured, untextured and convex analog sticks; the four- and eight-way D-Pads - return unchanged. They lock in magnetically and are easily replaceable on the fly.

(Image credit: Microsoft)

Beneath the replaceable nubs, though, the analog sticks sport a new twist. You can adjust the tension in the analog sticks by removing the analog sub and twisting a column inside the stick using the tool included with the kit or a small screwdriver. The distinctions between the three settings are fairly small, but the tighter sticks work well in competitive shooters like Gears 5 and fighting games like Mortal Kombat 11, where you want more precision control and a quicker snap back to neutral position.

The buttons and triggers have also gotten a little glow up. The buttons are now clicky and easier to tap, without the squish of the standard Xbox One controller - one of my favorite features in my favorite third-party controller, the Razer Wolverine Ultimate. The back of the controller has a pair of switches, which allow you to reduce the amount of travel on the triggers from a full press to half or even a “hair trigger” tap. Personally, I prefer the standard pull, but competitive players will likely want the lower actuation point of the quick-press.

I’m also very thankful that the Xbox Elite Series 2 controller now has a built-in battery, which gets about 30-40 hours of battery life in a charge. You can charge it using the controller’s USB-C port, which replaces the standard Micro-USB at the top of the controller, or use the wireless charging dock, which comes with device. The dock is just a small black box, so doesn’t take up much space or feel like an eyesore, and it’s convenient to grab your controller when its time to play and charge it up when you’re done. Some of these upgrades, like building in a battery and adding Bluetooth support like the second-generation Xbox One gamepad, feel more like modernization than upgrades - these are things you expect from a $180 controller - but features like the charging dock leap-frog what should be standard and make these improvements feel luxurious.

Xbox Elite Series 2 Software improvements

In my mind, the best improvements to the Xbox Elite Controller Series 2 are on the software side, though. As with the original Xbox Elite, you can completely remap the controller as you see fit using the Xbox Accessories app. The range of inputs you can map to each button, however, has expanded quite a bit. In addition to the buttons on the controller, you can also assign inputs to specific system-level actions like taking a screenshot, showing your achievements, or opening a specific app. If it was a Kinect voice command, you can map it to a button. It’s a huge boon for players who want to use the paddles and the face buttons together, rather simply use them as a finger-friendly replacement. You also have the ability to assign a “shift” button, which opens up a second set of alternative inputs.

(Image credit: Microsoft)

At any given time, you can set and rotate among three input profiles using a new button on the front of the controller, replacing the first Elite 2's profile switch. Don’t worry, there’s an LED indicator showing you which setting you’re on. You can also store extra profiles in the Xbox Accessories app on your Xbox and Windows. The three profiles on your controller get stored in onboard memory, so you can use them when you swap from device to device. You can also store and save profiles out of your rotation in the Accessories app, so there’s no reason not to try new things for every game. Those profiles get synced in the cloud, so you can access all your profiles, onboard or off, on any Xbox or Windows PC so long as you sign in with your Xbox account.

To me, though, the biggest improvement is simply how the Elite Series 2 feels in your hand. Though it is only three grams lighter - 345g versus 348g - the Elite Series 2 is much better balanced, so its weightiness is a strength rather than a weakness. The controller feels dense and durable, but you don’t notice you’re holding it the way you did with the original Elite and some of its premium competitors. I didn’t find myself putting it down as much during cutscenes and breaks.

(Image credit: Microsoft)

The Xbox Elite Controller Series 2 doesn’t reinvent the wheel, but at times it feels like a revolution. From taking a screenshot with a single paddle press, to wireless charging, to using tighter analog sticks, it stacks the deck with tweaks that make a huge difference depending on what games you play and what controller you’ve been using to play them. It truly is one of the best PC controllers, and of course a real contender for the best Xbox One controller. The only real downside is the price: how do you feel about spending $180 on a controller with a new Xbox right around the corner? Well, there's some good news, Microsoft has confirmed this controller will be supported by the upcoming Xbox Series X, meaning you'll get to use it for years to come.

Mike Epstein is now the Reviews Editor for Popular Science. However, he was once a freelance games and technology journalist covering video games and hardware reviews, features, and more. His words have appeared on Lifehacker, GamesRadar, IGN, Gamespot, PC Mag, and more.